Short answer
Choose customer loyalty software around the tools you already use and the work you want help with. Square is a starting point for a Square checkout, Yotpo for an online-store rewards program, and Loopy Loyalty for wallet stamp cards. Compare Rehost when you need the website, customer app, and loyalty program built and run together for one monthly price.
There is no single best choice for every business. A reward card, a program connected to checkout, and a managed website-and-app service cover different jobs.
This comparison uses public product pages checked on November 16, 2026. It is a shortlist for a small or medium-sized business, not a hands-on benchmark or an independent ranking. Features, support, and terms depend on the plan and your setup.
Compare four options by the job you need done
Start with the closest fit below. Then ask the provider to show your real customer journey before you buy.
| Option | What it covers | Check before choosing |
|---|---|---|
| Square Loyalty | Points for visits, spending, items, or categories through supported Square sales channels. | Your Square plan, locations, refund rules, and who runs the program. |
| Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals | Online-store loyalty with earning rules, rewards, referrals, and customer tiers. | Your store platform, included features, setup help, and any in-store connection. |
| Loopy Loyalty | Apple and Google Wallet stamp cards. Staff issue stamps and rewards with its Stamper App. | Visit checks, stamp corrections, staff users, locations, and plan limits. |
| Rehost Business | A website, customer app, and loyalty program built and run together in one monthly bundle. | Scope, connections, usage limits, outside fees, and the tasks your team keeps. |
Read the linked product pages and confirm the current plan. A published feature does not establish that it works with your exact checkout, booking tool, or customer records.
Keep a useful sales system if it already does the job
If you use Square, start by checking its rewards setup before adding another tool. Its product page describes earning and using rewards in supported in-store and online flows. Ask to see the transactions your business actually handles.
For an online store, include Yotpo in the comparison if its earning rules, referrals, or tiers match the program you want. Confirm which features and store connections are included in the proposed plan. A long feature list does not settle how your staff will use it.
These are reasons to investigate the options, not reasons to replace a working system. Name the tool that will keep the final sales record. Decide what happens when the rewards screen and the sales record disagree.
Before buying a connection, use our POS loyalty integration buyer’s guide. It covers customer matching, earning and using rewards, refunds, and the help to include in the quote.
Separate a wallet card from a customer app
Loopy Loyalty puts stamp cards in Apple and Google Wallet, so customers do not need a separate loyalty app for that card. Its staff stamping workflow still needs to fit the way your team checks eligible visits.
A wallet card can be enough if the main task is collecting stamps and using a reward. If customers also need ordering, booking, or account tools, check those tasks separately. Do not assume a stamp-card product includes a whole website and customer app.
Our small-business loyalty app buyer’s guide explains wallet cards, shared apps, branded apps, and managed bundles in more detail.
Ask who will do the work after launch
Software features and ongoing service are different parts of a quote. A provider may offer setup help or dedicated support without taking over every weekly task. Ask what the team actually does for you.
- Who writes reward rules and approves changes?
- Who checks missing points, refunds, and duplicate customer accounts?
- Who changes the website, app content, and customer messages?
- Who follows up when a connection to another tool fails?
- Who trains staff and answers customers’ program questions?
Put a person or team beside each job. Separate routine work from problems that need the provider’s help. Confirm response targets and included changes in writing.
Compare the full bill for the same scope
Ask each provider for a current quote using the same locations, customer activity, and required features. A trial or introductory rate is not the regular cost.
Include the software plan, setup, paid connections, messages, and any required sales-system plan. Add staff time, reward costs, and any separate website or app work you still need. Check which charges grow with usage and which services renew separately.
Compare the first year and a normal year after any offer ends. For each, ask what the bill would be if the program grows. Do not assume each provider counts customers, orders, locations, or messages in the same way.
For a line-by-line example, use our small-business loyalty program cost guide. It separates software fees, rewards, and the value of staff time so you can compare the work as well as the bill.
For Rehost, use the current bundle price and terms. The website, customer app, and loyalty program are included in one monthly bundle. The written scope confirms connections, vendor fees, and included work.
Use the same demo brief for each provider
Bring one normal purchase or completed visit, plus one case that tends to cause problems. Ask for a supported solution, not just a tour of the dashboard.
- Join as a new customer and check what details are required.
- Complete the eligible action and check when credit appears.
- Use a reward and confirm it cannot be used twice.
- Refund or cancel the action and review the balance.
- Find the right account after a changed phone number or email address.
- Show what staff do when the connection is unavailable.
For each step, mark the answer as supported, handled by staff, or outside the plan. Manual work may be acceptable for a small program. The important part is knowing what staff must do before customers join.
If you sell goods, our retail loyalty program guide covers purchase rules, returns, and online/in-store balances.
Check customer records and leaving terms
Ask what customer details, point balances, earned rewards, and activity history you can export. Confirm the file format, cost, and help available to move those records. Keep optional marketing choices separate from joining the program.
Before switching providers, read our loyalty program migration guide. It covers matching customers, moving balances and unused rewards, checking a test import, and agreeing on the changeover.
Get the notice period, final bill, and treatment of unused rewards in writing. If a website or app is part of the quote, check the domain, store accounts, licenses, and handoff too.
With Rehost, customers retain the content and data they submit. Rehost owns its software, code, and designs unless a signed agreement says otherwise. Accounts, licenses, exports, and service-end terms follow that agreement.
FAQ
Can loyalty software guarantee more repeat sales?
No. Choose a starting measure and review repeat paid visits or purchases, reward costs, and staff work. Vendor case studies and differences between members and non-members do not prove what the program will cause at your business.
Do we need to replace our checkout or booking system?
Not automatically. Check what your current tools already support. Any new connection depends on vendor access, account permissions, and the agreed work. Ask for a demonstration with your actual setup before deciding to replace it.
When is the Rehost bundle worth comparing?
When you need the website, customer app, and loyalty program built and run together. If the only gap is a simple reward card, a lighter tool may be enough. Compare the work included and the tasks your staff will keep.
Choose the fit you can explain to your team
Keep the shortlist small. Check the must-have customer tasks, the weekly work, the full bill, and what happens when you leave.
If you want all three parts handled together, explore Rehost’s website, app, and loyalty bundle and review the monthly pricing and written terms.