Key Takeaway
Church Center is a free companion app for Planning Center - great if you already use that system. But it offers minimal customization, no denomination-specific features, and no code ownership. Rehost builds fully custom church apps at $250/month where you own the code. Choose Church Center if you're deeply embedded in Planning Center. Choose Rehost for a custom, branded church app that stands on its own.
Two Different Philosophies
Church Center and Rehost approach church apps from completely different angles. Church Center is an extension of Planning Center - the popular church management system. It gives your congregation a mobile window into the Planning Center tools your staff already uses: check-ins, groups, registrations, and giving.
Rehost is a custom app development studio. You describe what your church needs, and a team builds it from scratch - tailored to your denomination, your branding, and your workflows. These are different solutions for different problems.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Church Center | Rehost |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | Free (requires Planning Center) | $250/mo |
| Planning Center required | Yes | No |
| Custom branded app | Limited (shared branding) | Yes (fully custom) |
| Code ownership | No | Yes |
| Denomination-specific features | No | Yes |
| Design customization | Minimal | Fully custom |
| Check-in integration | Yes (Planning Center) | Custom-built |
| Online giving | Yes (Planning Center Giving) | Yes (any provider) |
| Group management | Yes (Planning Center Groups) | Custom-built |
| Sermon library | No | Yes (searchable) |
| Prayer wall | No | Yes |
| Push notifications | Yes | Yes |
| Event registration | Yes (Planning Center Registrations) | Custom-built |
| Standalone app | No (depends on Planning Center) | Yes |
Choose Church Center If...
- Your church already uses Planning Center for daily operations (check-ins, groups, registrations)
- You want a free app that mirrors your existing Planning Center setup
- Your team is comfortable with Planning Center's interface and workflow
- You primarily need an app for check-ins, event registration, and giving - not content or engagement
- You're okay with Planning Center's branding appearing alongside yours
Choose Rehost If...
- You want an app that stands on its own - not dependent on a specific back-end system
- You need denomination-specific features - liturgical calendar for Lutherans, member management for Baptists, live worship integration for Pentecostal churches
- Code ownership matters - you want to own the app if you ever switch platforms
- You want a fully custom design that reflects your church's unique identity
- You need features Church Center doesn't offer: sermon library, prayer wall, devotional content
- You want flexibility in giving providers - Stripe, Tithe.ly, Pushpay, or any other processor
The Planning Center Lock-In Question
Church Center's biggest strength is also its biggest limitation: it's completely dependent on Planning Center. This means:
- If you ever leave Planning Center, your app stops working
- Your app's features are limited to what Planning Center modules offer
- You can't add features that Planning Center doesn't support
- You can't customize the app beyond Planning Center's options
For churches deeply invested in Planning Center (and happy to stay), this isn't a problem - the tight integration is actually a feature. But for churches that want future flexibility or features beyond Planning Center's scope, Rehost's custom approach provides independence.
The Real Cost of "Free"
Church Center is free, but Planning Center isn't. Here's what the full stack actually costs:
| Planning Center Modules | Monthly Cost |
|---|---|
| People (required) | Free–$99/mo |
| Check-Ins | Free–$149/mo |
| Giving | Free–$99/mo |
| Groups | Free–$99/mo |
| Registrations | Free–$99/mo |
| Total (all modules, mid-tier) | $100–$400/mo |
| Rehost (everything included) | $250/mo |
If you're using multiple Planning Center modules at the paid tier, the "free" Church Center app is sitting on top of $100–400/month in subscription costs. Rehost at $250/month includes everything in a single custom-built package.
Related: Best Subsplash Alternatives | Tithe.ly vs Rehost | Shoutem vs Rehost | Pushpay vs Rehost
FAQ
Is Church Center really free?
The Church Center app itself is free, but it requires a Planning Center subscription to function. Planning Center offers free tiers for small churches but paid modules range from $14–$149/month each. Most churches using multiple modules pay $100–400/month total for Planning Center.
Can Church Center work without Planning Center?
No. Church Center is entirely dependent on Planning Center. It's a front-end for Planning Center's back-end systems. Without an active Planning Center subscription, the Church Center app has no content or functionality.
Can I switch from Church Center to Rehost?
Yes. Rehost can build a custom church app that replaces Church Center while integrating with your existing giving provider, communication tools, and management systems. You can continue using Planning Center for back-end operations while using a Rehost app as the congregation-facing experience.